A Review of Pressure Tube Failure Accident in the CANDU Reactor and Methods for Improving Reactor Performance

  • Published : 1998.06.01

Abstract

The experiences and causes of pressure tube cracking accidents in the CANDU reactors and the development of the fuel channel at AECL(Atomic Energy Canada Limited) have been described. Most of the accidents were caused by Delayed Hydride Cracking(DHC). In the cases of the Pickering units 3&4 and the Bruce unit 2, excessive residual stresses induced by an improper rolled joint process played a role in DHC. In the Pickering unit 2, cracks formed by contact between the pressure and calandria tubes due to the movement of the garter spring were the direct cause of the failure. To extend the life of a fuel channel, several R&D programs examining each component of the fuel channel have been carried out in Canada. For a pressure tube, the main concern is focused on changing the fabrication processes, e.g., increasing cold working rate, conducting intermediate annealing and adding a third element like Fe, V, and Cr to the tube material. In addition to them, chromium plating on the end fitting and increasing wall thickness at both ends of the calandria tube are considered. There has also been much interest in the improvement of fuel channel performance in our country and several development programs are currently under way.

Keywords

References

  1. AECL-6059 Pickering Pressure tube cracking experience E.C.W. Perryman
  2. AECL-5261 Some Engineering Aspects of the investigation into the Cracking of Pressure Tubes in the Pickering Reactors P.A. Ross;J.T. Dunn
  3. AECL-7537 Replacement of a Cracked Pressure tube in Bruce GS unit 2 A.H. Jackman
  4. AECL-8335 Analysis of the Pressure Tube Failure at Pickering NGS G.H. Field;J.T. Dunn;B.A. Cheadle
  5. AECL-8755 An Outline of the Comprehensive investigation into the Cause of Failure of a Pressure Tube in Pickering N.G.S. Unit 2 E.G. Price
  6. AECL-9126 Minimizing Hydride Cracking in Zirconium Alloys C.E. Coleman;B.A. Cheadle
  7. Zirconium in the Nucler Industry : Seventh International Symposium Prevention of Delayed Hydride Cracking in Zirconium B.A. Creadle;C.E. Coleman
  8. Merall. Trans. v.8A Mechanisms of Hydrogen Induced Delayed Cracking in Hydride Forming Materials R. Dutton;K. Nuttall
  9. AECL-5260 Susceptibility of cold-worked Zirconium-2.5% Niobium Alloy to Delayed Hydrides Cracking C.E. Coleman
  10. AECL-2624 Stress Reorientation of Hydrides in cold-worked Zirconium-2.5 Niobium Pressure Tubes G.W. Perry
  11. AECL-7538 CANDU-PHW Fuel Channel Replacement Experience J.T. Dunn;B.K. Kakaria
  12. AECL-9753 Fuel Channel Performance G.L. Brooks;E.G. Price
  13. AECL-11059 Advances in Fuel Channel Technology for CANDU reactors B.A. Cheadle;C.E. Coleman
  14. Tenth international symposium on zirconium in the nuclear industry Fabrication of Zr-2.5Nb pressure tubes to inimize the hamful effects if trace elements J. Theaker;R. Choubey;G.D. Moan