Comparison of Growth Charateristics, Forage Yield and Growth Analysis in Corn Hybrids for Silage Production

Silage용 옥수수의 생육특성, 수량 및 생육해석의 품종간 비교

  • Published : 1998.06.30

Abstract

This experiment was conducted from May to August in 1997 to selected the wrn hybrids being suitable for silage at farm in the Kongju National University through the comparison of growth characteristics, forage yield and growth analysis about native and imported corn hybrids for silage production. In this experiment, trial design was a randomized block design with three replication, testing varieties were 4 hybrids (Suwon 19, Kwanganok, Whengsungok, Suwonok ) of native corn hybrids and 13 hybrids (P 3156, P 3352, P 3144w, DK 501, DK 689, DK 713, DK 729, H 643.99, H 545.64, H 645.12, HC 7466, H 644.18, H ALISEO) of imported corn hybrids. The results obtained are summarized as follows; 1. The emergence rate of H643.99 was the highest with 97.0%. In rice black streaked dwarf virus(RBSOV), the hybrid of HC 7466 was lower infected with 1.6% than other hybrids. The plant hight of P 3144w was the highest with 339 cm and the stem length of P 3156 was the highest with 261 cm. In native com hybrids, the plant height and stem length of Kwanganok were recorded with 306 cm and 235 cm, respectively. 2. Leaf number and leaf area of Kwanganok were the greatest with 16 sheet per plant and $5,180\;{\textrm{m}^2}/l0a$, respectively. H 645.12 and H 545.64 had the greatest in ear to total dry matter ratio with 49.5% and 49.4%, respectively. 3. The fresh matter yield was significantly difference between growth stage, So Suwon 19 had the most level at 15 days before silking, P 3352 had the most level at silking date, Kwananok had the most level at 35 days a after silking. The fresh matter yield of native com hybrids such as Suwon 19 and Kwanganok was not apparent diffreences as compared with imported corn hybrids. 4. As the results of survey with dry weight, the quantity of dry matter accumulation were increase after silking. The varieties of P 3352, P 3156, Kwanganok, OK 713 were more quantity of dry matter production than DK 501, HC 7466. The Kwanganok of native com hybrid and Pioneer strain with high percentage of dry matter were higher dry weight than Limagrain strain. 5. HC 7466 had the largest LAR with $6.53\;{\textrm{cm}^2}/g$, H545.12 had the lowest LAR with $3.30\;{\textrm{cm}^2/g}$. P 3144 had the largest LAI, DeKalb strain including DK 713 were larger apparently than Limagrain strain including HC 7466 with 3.15. 6. The RGR of testing varieties was little difference of statistical significantly, but DK 501, and HC 7466 were lower than other corn hybrids. The CGR of native and American varieties was no apparent differences, but that of Limagrain strains were a large variation. According to the results obtained by this experiment, the eary growth such as emergence rate and RBSDV infection rate of Limagrain strains was more excellent than other strains. P 3156, P 3352, P 3144w, DK 713 and HC 7466 were suitable for silage condition such as dry matter yield, percentage of dry matter and % ear to total dry matter. The fresh and dry matter yield of native corn hybrids such as Suwon 19 and Kwanganok were not apparent differences as compared with imported corn hybrids, but percentage of dry matter was lower than other imported corn hybrids.

본 시험은 최적 Silage 옥수수 품종을 선발하는데 필요한 기초자료를 얻기 위하여 국내산 옥수수 4품종 (수원 19호, 광안옥, 횡성옥, 수원옥)과 외국 도입 Silage용 품종으로 미국계통 7품종 (P 3144 W, P 3352, P 3156, DK 501, DK 729, DK 713, DK 689)과 프랑스 Limagrain계통 6품종(H 545.64, H 645.12, H 643.99, He 7466, H 644.18, H ALISEO) 총 17품종의 생육특성, 수량 및 생장해석을 비교 분석하고자 실시 하였으며 실험설계는 품종을 란괴법 3반부으로 공주대학교 산업과학대학 실험포장에서 1997년 5월부터 8월까지 시행하였다. 그 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 1. 생육특성으로 출현솔은 H 643.99 품종이 97.0% 로 가장 높았고, 흑조강축병 권병솔은 HC 7466 품종이 1.6 %로 가장 낮았다. 초장과 정장은 Pioneer 계통이 커서 초장은 P 3144w 품종이 339 cm로 가장 컸으며, 정장은 P 3156 품종이 261 cm로 가장 컸다. 우리나라 품종으로는 광안옥이 비교적 초장파 정장이 커서 각각 306 cm와 235 cm로 나타났다. 경직경은 DK 689 품종이 3.7 cm로 가장 굵었다. 2. 엽수와 엽면적은 광안옥이 각각 16.0매 와 $5,180\;{\textrm{m}^2}/10a$로 가장 높았으며, 암이삭 비율에 있어서는 H 645.12와 H 545.64 품종들이 각각 49.5와 49.4 %로 높게 나타났다. 3. 생초수량은 생육기에 따라 차이가 있어 출사전 15일에는 수원 19호가 출사기에는 P 3352 품종이, 출사 후 35일에는 광안옥이 가장 높아 우리나라 품종들이 도입 품종들보다 생초수량이 떨어지지 않았다. 4. 건물수량은 출사 후 중가 폭이 컸으며, 품종간의 건물수량은 생육기에 따라 약간의 차이는 있으나 P 3352, P 3156, 광안옥, DK 713의 품종들이 높았고, DK 501과 HC 7466 품종들이 낮았다. 출사 후 35일 경에는 품종간에도 유의성이 커서 우리나라 품종인 광안옥과 건물솔이 높은(29.6~30.2%) Pioneer 계통의 품종들이 수량이 많았으며 , Limagrain 계통의 Hybrid 품종들이 대체로 건물수량이 낮았다. 5. LAR은 HC 7466 품종이 $6.53\;{\textrm{cm}^2}/g$으로 제일 높았으며, 가장 낮은 품종은 H 545.12로 $3.30\;{\textrm{cm}^2}/g$이었다. LAI는 P 3144w가 제일 컸으며, HC 7466 품종의 3.15를 비롯하여 Limagrain 계통 품종들이 낮게 나타났다. 6. RGR은 품종간에 통계적 유의성은 없었으나 DK 501과 HC 7466 품종은 타 품종에 비해 떨어지는 경향을 보였으며, 국내품종과 미국계통 품종들은 CGR에 별 차이가 없으나, 프랑스의 Limagrain 계통 품종들 간에는 CGR의 변이가 크게 나타났다. 이상의 결과로 볼 때 출현솔 및 흑조강축병 이병솔은 Limagrain 계통 품종들이 양호하게 나타났으며, 사일리지 옥수수용 품종의 조건인 건물수량, 건물솔 및 암이삭비율 등은 P 3156, P 3352, P 3144w, DK 713, HC 7466 품종들이 우수한 것으로 나타났다. 우리나라 품종인 수원 19호와 광안옥도 생초수량과 건물수량은 타 도입 품종보다 떨어 지 지 않으나 건물솔이 낮게 나타났다.

Keywords