Determination on the Optimal Sample Size in the Aquatic Insect Community Analysis - Pangtae Creek Model

수서곤충 군집분석에 있어서 최적표본크기의 결정 - 방태천 모형

  • Published : 1998.02.01

Abstract

A molel study was conducted to determine the optimal sample size for the analysis of the aquatic insect community in a stream reach of the Pangtae Creek, Kangwon-do in October 1995 and may 1996. The results showed that the required minimum sample size varied and depended on the purposes of the community analysis. Acoording to the Species: Area Curve method, at least 16 Surber samplings ($30{\times}30cm$) were required in a stream reach in each spring and fall survey. The species diversity index did not vary significantly as the sample size increased. Based on the coefficient of variation analysis, the minimum sample sizes of 10 were required in order to compare seasonal differences of the community in the study area. Considering the static community structure of aquatic insects, including both species numbers and individual numbers of aquatic insects, 11 and 7 samplings were optimal sizes for the fall and spring survey, respectively. We concluded that 12 Surber samplings from 3 riffle-pool sequences (4 samplings at each riffle-pool sequence) would be required in a stream reach (length 1 km) to obtain reliable as well as cost efficient data. Our model showed that the optimal sample size should be determined by interactions between minimum sample size, the degree of data reliability, and cost efficiency.

Keywords

References

  1. 한국육수학회지 v.28 강원도 방태천 수서곤충 군집의 생태학적 특성 박정호;조규송
  2. '96 한국육수학회 심포지움 강연록 한국 수서곤충 연구의 현황과 과제 배연재
  3. 한국동식물도감 제30권 동물편 (수서곤충류) 윤일병
  4. 수서곤충검색도설 윤일병
  5. 자연보존협회연구보고서 no.35 방태산 북사면 일대 종합학술조사 연구보고서. 한국자연보존협회
  6. Stream ecology: Structure and function of running waters. Allan, J.D.
  7. Ecology: Individuals, populations and communities. Bagon, M.;J.L. Harper;C.R. Townsend
  8. Laboratory and field manual of ecology. Brewer, R;M.T. McCann
  9. Freshwater Biol. Assoc. Sci. Publ.(2nd ed.) v.25 Some methods for the statistical analysis of samples of benthic invertebrates Elliott, J.M.
  10. An illustrated book of aquatic insects of Japan. Kawai, T.
  11. Limnol. Oceanogr. v.17 Underestimation of standing crop by the Surber sampler. Kroger, R.L.
  12. Information theory in ecology. Gen. Syst. v.3 Margalef, R.
  13. Arch. Hydrobiol. v.78 Evaluating a substrate tray for sampling the invertebrate fauna of small streams, with comments on general sampling problems. Mason, J.C.
  14. Aquatic entomology. McCafferty, W.P.
  15. An introduction to the aquatic insects of North America.(3rd ed.) Merrit, R.W.;K.W. Cummins
  16. J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc. v.16 Empirical models predicting population abundance productivity in lotic systems. Morin, A.
  17. J. Theor. Biol. v.13 The measurement of diversity in different types of biological succession. Pielou, E.C.
  18. Population and community ecology - principle and methods. Pielou, E.C.
  19. J. Fish. Res. Board Can. v.36 Sampling variability and life history features: Basic considerations in the design of aquatic insect studies. Resh, V.H.
  20. SAS/STAT User's guide(Version 6)(4th Edition) v.1 SAS Institute Inc.
  21. Ecological methods. Sowthwood, T.R.E.
  22. J. N. Am. Benthol. Soc. v.15 Effects of sampling area and subsampling procedure on comparisons of taxa richness among streams. Vinson, M.R.;C.P. Hawkins.
  23. Larvae. Entomol. Scand. Suppl. v.19 Chironomidae of the holarctic region Wiederholm, T.