A Study for Comparison of Risk Estimates According to Extrapolating Methods of Benzo(a)Pyrene in the Ambient Air

대기중 Benzo(a) pyrene의 외삽방법에 따른 위해도 추계치의 비교 연구

  • Kim, Jong-Man (The Institute for Environmental Research, Yonsei University) ;
  • Chung, Yong (The Institute for Environmental Research, Yonsei University)
  • 김종만 (연세대학교 환경공해연구소) ;
  • 정용 (연세대학교 환경공해연구소)
  • Published : 1992.03.01

Abstract

The risk of benzo(a)pyrene for cancer in the ambient air of Seoul was assessed by using the extrapolation methods. The average daily lifetime exposure of benzo(a)pyrene in the ambient air of Seoul was calculated at 6.97-24.30ng/$m^2$/day, which was based on the occurrence analysis of benzo(a)pyrene in the residential(Bull Kwang Dong) and traffic areas(Shin Chon) of Seoul. Using the dose scaling based on body surface area in comparisons of toxicity for extrapolation from animal to human and mathematical models from the high dose region, the low-dose risk was estimated. The response probabilities were estimated by the tolerance distribution models; Probit, Logit and Weibull model. They were consistent with the observed ones at experimental dose region. The unit risk estimates of these models were too low to be used. One-hit and multistage model to prove more conservative risk was selected. As a redult, the lifetime unit risk of benzo(a)pyrene for cancer and virtually safe dose were calculated; One-hit model provided the risk 2.8 $\times 10^{-7}$ and 3.4ng/$m^3$, respectively and multistage model provided 5.2 $\times 10^{-7}$ and 1.9ng/$m^3$ as the more conservatives. The lifetime excess risk estimates of benzo(a)pyrene for cancer were calculated at 0.37-1.30 persons/million persons by one-hit model and 0.69-2.41 persons/million persons by multistage model, which was considered in without virtual risk.

Keywords

References

  1. 한국대기보전학회지 v.6 no.2 대기부유분진중 미량 유해물질들의 통계적오염해석 손동헌(외 4인)
  2. 연세대학교 대학원 박사학위 논문 도시대기중 유기오염물질 농도와 돌연변이 원성에 대한 연구 신동천
  3. Institute of Environ Med Temporal aspects of tumorigenic response to individual and mixed carcinogens Albert,R.E.(et al.)
  4. chemiche and biologische. analyse. v.41 Vergleichende schwebstaubmessungen zwischen Seoul(Korea) und Berlin(West) physikalische Chung,Y.(et al.)
  5. Science v.186 Urban aerosol toxicity : the influence of particle size David,F.S.(et al.)
  6. Regul. Toxicol. Phamacol. v.6 Biological Basis for extrapolation across mammalian species Davidson,I.W.F.(et al.)
  7. JAPCA v.16 Polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons associated with particulates in Pittslourgh air Demaio,I.;M.Corn
  8. Europ. J. cancer v.9 Dose-response correlation for the induction of respiratory-tract tumors in syrian golden hamsters by intratracheal installation of benzo(a) pyrene Feron,V.J.(et al.)
  9. Atoms Environ v.5 On the size distribution of benzo(a) pyrene containing particles in urban air Kertesz-Saringer,M.
  10. Gann v.66 Production of respiratory tract tumors in hamsters by beuzo(a) pyrene Kobayash,N.
  11. Atmos Environ v.12 Distribution of benzo(a) pyreme and coronene with respect to particle size in Pasadena aerosols in the submicron range Mignel,A.H.;S.K.Friedlander
  12. Food. Cosmet. Toxicol. v.19 Risk assessment and regulatory decision-making Munro,I.C.;D.R.Krewski
  13. Polycyclic Hydrocarbons and Cancer NagaO,M.T.Sugimura
  14. JAPCA v.37 no.7 In-depth exposure assessment Paul,J.L.
  15. Science v.221 Science, Risk and Public policy Ruckelshaus,W.D.
  16. Biomed. Mass. Spectroom. v.7 On the relevance of air pllution measurements of aliphatic and polyaromatic hydrocarbons in ambient particulates matter Van,Vaeck L.(et al.)
  17. Regul toxicol phamacol v.8 Extrapolation of animal toxicity data to man Vocci,F.;T.Farber
  18. Air guality guidences for Europe no.European Series No 23 WHO